Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Wency's avatar

I've been watching this PA race from afar. The debate between Oz and Fetterman was really something, and if that debate was all we had to go on, Oz would destroy Fetterman.

The counterpoint is that PA is really a Blue state and that 2016 was just a quirk of a year that won't be repeated. I guess some people will argue that Philadelphia is electorally a hyper-fraudulent place, and I'll probably believe you, but if a state reliably votes Blue, whether due to fraud or otherwise, I'm going to call it a Blue state.

I wonder if Fetterman would have been better off adopting the Tommy Tuberville strategy of refusing to debate his opponent, go on TV, etc. Just let the party brand (and antipathy to the Trump brand) carry him, run some ads about how Oz is a quack. Unlike Tuberville, Fetterman also has the MSM to cover for him to and to highlight Oz's quackery at every opportunity. Tuberville might make some gaffes, but his strategy of acting like HE was the incumbent and Doug Jones was a deranged homeless man claiming to be a candidate for US Senate was apparently the right one.

It's hard to see how Fetterman had much to gain from the contrast of his TV appearance and presentation skills to those of Oz, even before his stroke. After the stroke, he's so bad that it makes everyone uncomfortable.

Expand full comment
Andrew's avatar

It's more likely that the difference between Metaculus and PredictIt/Polymarket is a first order effect of how it's structured - rewarding low information predictions on lots of questions vs rewarding beating the market - than the second order effect of how this structure effects what politics the people who use the platform agree with.

If you're a low information predictor taking 1 minute to answer each question on Metaculus, the most effective way to predict is to pull up the polls and adjust by whatever amount you think they are biased by. If you're a no information predictor taking 10 seconds to answer questions, the most effective prediction is just to put in the same guess as everybody else. On real money markets, there's no incentive to make predictions on questions where you don't have an opinion.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts