Discussion about this post

User's avatar
PatrickB's avatar

Another thing about idealists: they tend to blend “religion” and “ideas” in that gives the appearance of causal efficacy to the latter. Of course, religion involves ideas (things like scripture, creeds, catechism and affiliated intellectuals). But religion also involves communal rituals, belonging, doing things together like bible study or going to church on Sunday. Even in religion, the idea space is crowded! So, idealists should be expected to show why certain ideas are put into practice and how intensely. They don’t show this, because, lo and behold, ideas don’t make that call. Instead, the selection and emphasis comes from (1) which ideas are enforced or (2) the congregation’s sense of identity, or being on the same team. Enforcement, that there is some consequence for transgressing an ideas as applied, is thru policing, communal or hierarchical as formal or informal institutions, sometimes backed by the state, permit. Often, as anyone who’s been in a church knows, such policing is sparked by petty and narrow beefs and envy, not unlike wokeness!

Sense of identity can be pre-sectarian or inculcated thru communal rituals. For the former, note how black and white protestant congregations have acted differently despite having nearly identical doctrine. For the latter, the key point is that congregants are actually doing something together to bind as a congregation, which develops their sense of collective interest. They aren’t just pondering and reading in their rooms in isolation.

In my experience, idealists are the type of people who read and think. They imagine an alternative status hierarchy where thinking is apical. They latch on to “religion” to defend their worldview. But their concept of religion is bogus. Again, just from my own experience so I could be wrong, idealists tend to think they’re too smart to go to mass or bible study, which would involve interacting with people (too argumentative) or sitting thru a ritual (boring, also nerds can’t dance). For idealists who actually go to church, I would also venture that simply going to service, without accountability to or interaction with co-congregants, is more entertainment or emotional catharsis than religion.

Long story short, idealist have read about “religion.” But they simply have no idea of what being in congregation is like.

Expand full comment
Sinclair's avatar

In an online discussion on privacy recently i’ve seen people say they would take legal action if the site was not made gdpr compliant. This is how you end up in a world where all websites everywhere displays annoying cookie banners. The law is a socially acceptable way to threaten people and people casually do it all the time

Expand full comment
38 more comments...

No posts