Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Yaw's avatar

Great read, I agree WNF has fundamental flaws on not weighing human capital enough, and I hope that one day Acemoglu comes around and weighs markets more importantly than he currently does. Although I don't find that likely.

Another thing that should make him reconsider his thesis is basically the cases of China vs India and Vietnam vs Philippines..

China and Vietnam are both one party autocracies countries that reformed to become more market oriented in the 1980s (Gaige Kanfang under Deng Xiaopeng in China and Doi Moi under Nguyễn Văn Linh in Vietnam). In the late 1980s, India was still richer per capita than China but by the 1990s, China blew past india.

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GNP.PCAP.CD?end=2002&locations=CN-IN&start=1962

I remember Acemoglu said in his book something along the lines of "while autocracies can be fast growing for some time, they cant sustain it. Look at the Soviets, they grew fast after WWII but stagnate by the Brezhnev era and was only hanging on by oil exports after the 1973 crisis and the 1979 iranian oil production drop post Iranian revolution. But by the 1980s when the oil glut happened the Soviet Union was fucked." But that argument is basically, "i know it seems that autocracies can grow fast, but give it time and i'll be vindicated". The issue is not only is that argument non-falsifiable, but even if you placebo test the "give it time, and you'll see that country stagnate" argument applies to democracies as well. Brazil and post apartheid South Africa were both fast growing in the early 2000s. But stagnated after 2014, because it turns out their growth was caused by commodity booms fueled by China but when China's import demand slowed down 2014-2015, so did these economies, and stagnated since over the last 10 years.

Vietnam vs. Philippines is probably another great counter. Philippines was quite literally the 4th richest asian country per capita post WWII losing only to Japan, Hong Kong, and Singapore. It was slightly richer than Malaysia, and much richer than Taiwan, South Korea, Indonesia and more. It had the highest adult literacy in east asia and had constitutional government modelled after the U.S. Meanwhile Vietnam was basically in four consecutive wars with major powers since WWII (Japan during WWII, France during decolonization, then America, then a brief border war with China after Vietnam invaded Cambodia), was sanctioned hard by the US, and then after market reforms with Doi Moi we now see Vietnam becoming slightly richer than the Philippines.

I wrote more about that Vietnam vs. Philippines here if you are interested. But it seems clear that with time, Acemoglu will have to update his model about inclusive political institutions being a prereq for growth.

https://yawboadu.substack.com/p/the-2026-world-bank-scorecard-vietnam?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=garki

Dave92f1's avatar

Singapore has regular and *mostly* fair elections. The PAP cares deeply about retaining the support of the electorate.

But aside from that, you're right here. Hong Kong had no elections at all. China doesn't have democracy worthy of the name. Yet capitalism reliably leads to widespread wealth.

41 more comments...

Ready for more?