Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michiel's avatar

That Matthew Adelstein quote is absurd. Of course there is a moral difference between killing an animal because we like the smell of the dead animal, and killing it because eating animals is what we do to stay alive. Now, are there other things we can eat to stay alive? Yes, but humans are naturally omnivorous so eating animals is at least as natural as eating plants or nuts. Animals kill other animals in even more cruel ways (often by eating them alive) than humans do.

Of course that doesn't mean we should mistreat animals before they are slaughtered.

Expand full comment
Željka Buturović's avatar

If factory farming is really the worst crime in world history, then every single person, except for a handful of vegans, is (many times?), literally and metaphorically, worse than hitler, ted bundy, idi amin, nero etc. and when philosophical exercise leads you to such a conclusion, it's much more likely that are you operating beyond the limit of usefulness of your theoretical framework (e.g. utilitarianism), than that you are grasping big truths.

Expand full comment
224 more comments...

No posts