Jesus: Ancient Revolutionary, but Not the Father of the Enlightenment
Review of Tom Holland's Dominion
Flavius Claudius Julianus, who ruled as Roman Emperor from 361 to his death in 363 CE, is known to history as Julian the Apostate. As his moniker suggests, he rejected Christianity and sought a return to paganism. In 362, Julian wrote a letter to the high priest of Galatia. He was concerned by the decline of traditional religion, including the neglected state of the temple of the goddess Cybele in Pessinus, a city in central Anatolia. In his letter, Julian ordered the priests to spend more time trying to improve the lives of the less fortunate.
The religion of the Greeks does not yet prosper as I would wish, on account of those who profess it. But the gifts of the gods are great and splendid, better than any prayer or any hope…Why then do we think that this is sufficient and do not observe how the kindness of Christians to strangers, their care for the burial of their dead, and the sobriety of their lifestyle has done the most to advance their cause?…
Erect many hostels, one in each city, in order that strangers may enjoy my kindness, not only those of our own faith but also of others whosoever is in want of money. I have just been devising a plan by which you will be able to get supplies. For I have ordered that every year throughout all Galatia 30,000 modii of grain and 60,000 pints of wine shall be provided. The fifth part of these I order to be expended on the poor who serve the priests, and the rest must be distributed from me to strangers and beggars. For it is disgraceful when no Jew is a beggar and the impious Galileans [i.e., Christians] support our poor in addition to their own; everyone is able to see that our coreligionists are in want of aid from us. [emphasis added] Teach also those who profess the Greek religion to contribute to such services, and the villages of the Greek religion to offer the first-fruits to the gods. Accustom those of the Greek religion to such benevolence, teaching them that this has been our work from ancient times. Homer, at any rate, made Eumaeus say: "O Stranger, it is not lawful for me, even if one poorer than you should come, to dishonor a stranger. For all strangers and beggars are from Zeus. The gift is small, but it is precious." Do not therefore let others outdo us in good deeds while we ourselves are disgraced by laziness; rather, let us not quite abandon our piety toward the gods…
We ought to share our goods with all men, but most of all with the respectable, the helpless, and the poor, so that they have at least the essentials of life. I claim, even though it may seem paradoxical, that it is a holy deed to share our clothes and food with the wicked: we give, not to their moral character but to their human character. Therefore I believe that even prisoners deserve the same kind of care.
A concern for the poor and marginalized supposedly went back to Homer! In his mind, Julian was encouraging the Greeks to return to their charitable and humane roots.
Tom Holland argues that the Emperor was deluding himself. The Greek gods thought little of the poor and sick. They were warriors, and sometimes murderers and rapists, traits they shared with the human and semi-divine heroes of The Iliad and The Odyssey. Julian, who was raised a Christian, had taken the values of that faith for granted so much that he imagined their existence across the entire history of Greek culture.
