Discussion about this post

User's avatar
RenOS's avatar

It's insane how much we're arguably already living in the world that AI pessimists fear, i.e. only a minority of people are involved in important productive work that we actually need, and an even smaller percentage are involved in important research and development that has a realistic shot at improving our society.

Many people already waste substantial percentages of their life on unproductive endeavours, and/or choose service sector jobs that are as much a service to themselves as to others. Streamers or game developers are of course the purest examples, but many coffee shop owners, political activists, or almost anything relating to pets, particularly expensive ones like horses, and of course sports, as you mentioned. Anyone who has interacted with it knows that the bureaucracy is partially a place to generate make-work for people who wouldn't cut it anywhere else, and another part is actively inhibiting productive work of others. And most people I know who work in large companies will have plenty of stories of dysfunction, bloat and inefficiency, even if the company might at least in principle do something worthwhile.

If the percentage of work humans perform which is objectively important goes from 10% to 1%, would the average person even notice? 1% to 0.1%? Does it matter to their day-to-day? I don't think so. And as you say, entertainment, make-work and status games can be indefinitely generated for the rest.

Almost everyone is simultaneously too cynical and not even nearly cynical enough.

My bigger worry is the possibility of disenfranchisement if the AI really is that much better than us, becomes fully agentic and holds the majority of the levers of power, but there are quite a few more steps from here to there.

Scott Sumner's avatar

Excellent post. This is interesting to think about:

"He was only wrong in assuming that the work week would be shortened, when in reality we simply extended the periods of life during which humans don’t engage in the labor force."

People often make fun of Keynes's prediction, but (as you suggest) much of our current work is actually a disguised form of play. If you subtract all the time office workers spend surfing the web and chatting with coworkers, I wonder if we don't already have the very short work week that Keynes predicted.

68 more comments...

Ready for more?