Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Aaron Bozzi's avatar

In my town of Guilford, CT (population 22,000, voted 66% Biden in 2020, up from 59% Obama in 2012 and 57% Kerry in 2004) the school board race last year was highly contentious. A group of conservative parents decisively defeated the incumbent Republican board members who had gone along with the covid restrictions (a hybrid 2-day-a-week in person schedule for the 2020-2021 school year) and the woke superintendent's CRT agenda (auditing the curriculum, instituting "social-emotional learning" and "diversity and inclusion" plans, buying every teacher a copy of Kendi's book, hiring diversity officers and consultants, creating teaching positions restricted to nonwhite applicants etc. etc.). There was no chance of the conservatives actually taking over the majority of the school board and being able to make decisions. We would have merely replaced 3 go-with-the-flow Republicans with 3 anti-woke (but not outspokenly Trump-y) Republicans on the 9 person board. Nonetheless the response was hysterical and utterly ruthless by the liberal majority in town. Since Democrats were prevented from taking all the open seats based on both a state law and the town charter that provide for minority party representation on all town boards (hooray for pluralism), they and their allies just created an "independent party" and then the Democrats ran a joint campaign for their own and the "independent" candidates. In the end the anti-woke Republicans all lost approximately 67-33 (slightly larger margin than Trump lost by year before) in an incredibly high off-year-turnout (61%) election and so got no representation at all on the school board (it's now 5 woke Democrats and 4 woke "independents"). I really wish I knew what was working so well in Florida's blueish counties to let conservative candidates improve so much on prior Republican performance. In my town it seems the tribalism now runs so deep that no progress has been possible. I think the town demographics (90% white, with 58% having at least a bachelors and 31% having an advanced degree) work against us in the context of your assertion of the Democrats as the "high status" party, since lots of people here just could never even consider voting for the deplorable party even if they have reservations about individual policies.

Expand full comment
Nate's avatar

"[F]or conservatives to get their way on social issues, they need ... the state government, the local school boards, and the courts. Or at least two out of three."

Indeed. RH is correct. Controlling most political offices is really the only way to offset the enormous "soft" power of academia, the "helping" professions, civil service, and most jobs requiring a graduate degree – roles where right-leaning people scarcely exist. As you point out in your "Why Is Everything Liberal" article, the proles make up a majority of conservative voters and they will never flood the institutions due to an inward contentedness that arises from some combination of culture and psychological traits (and perhaps, I suspect, genetics). So, the difficult task of needing to control nearly all electoral/judicial slots will not go away. The proles can't be fixed.

If some of mainstream metropolitan culture became intelligently right-wing in terms of merit, genetics, treatment of criminality, and thoughtful public policy ... there may be hope. The guys at CSPI are a good example of the smart, metropolitan Right that I would like to see.

Expand full comment
68 more comments...

No posts