Discussion about this post

User's avatar
scf0101's avatar

Commenters here chastising Richard for ignoring genetics is truly beautiful.

Expand full comment
Leo Abstract's avatar

Brilliant application of Goodhart's law, which states the fastest way to get information from the internet is not to ask a question but to confidently proclaim a wrong answer. Richard's incorrect attempt to explain why racism is the cause of disparate outcomes is meant to invite us, the commentariat, to supply the correct one. So far, seventeen comments in, no-one has. I guess it falls to me.

Kendi's groundbreaking work on stereotype within the US is too nuanced to be simply ported over one-to-one in Asia. Yes, East Asians here are subject to stereotype, and yes stereotypes exist also in Asia. However, in their home environment East Asians share something in common: light skin. All define themselves in contradistinction to 'dumb', 'lazy', brown and indigenous people of color. East Asians are the white people of Asia, and similarly benefit from racism and stereotype there. They, like the white people of Europe, were fortunate enough to gain political and technological power that they use to subjugate and exploit BIPOC they encounter. All of the non-white, non-East-Asian countries we can compare with are full of innocent beautiful brown bodies who are held down by racism. We don't have a control-group world in which these other peoples were allowed to thrive wtih which to compare the world we have.

Expand full comment
206 more comments...

No posts