Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jose Guatemala's avatar

Strange to read something that basically says "things are going to continue on pretty much as they always have, etc." and it leave me feeling like I just took the biggest black pill.

Also, are u okay, bro? Have u given up? If I took this article seriously then I wouldn't really have any reason to continue reading your work (sorry I dont pay, inflation and 4 mouths to feed and all that). And honestly, if this is how u feel then why write anything else on these topics?

Darij Grinberg's avatar

> I’ve always had a visceral dislike of what I call “normie theories of democracy.” We are told that democracy works because it provides checks and balances, allows for the peaceful transfer of power, and the correction of mistakes.

I think a semi-implicit condition of these theories is that this democracy allows for radical opposition, some amount of riotous protests and at least plausible outside challenge (military or economic). The existence of the Sweden-Democrats forced the Social-Democrats to move back to the middle; Giorgia Meloni's ascendance is likely going to discourage future heavy-handed lockdowns in Italy; the shadow of the Kiev Majdan prevented Zelensky from making any overly strong concessions to Russia (even though he was elected as a dove). Ironically, the "most Western" countries like the US, Germany and France are the ones where these conditions are least satisfied: In Germany, the government has been keeping the Right out of ruling coalitions through a ridiculous informal system of "secondary sanctions" (the most famous case being https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_Thuringian_government_crisis ); the French Right is constantly battling what in the US would be considered brazen SLAPP lawsuits; and then there is the US, where some parts of the GOP are doing everything they can to speed up their ostracism.

My pet theory is that there is a "size penalty" in force here: Not just democracy, but any kind of responsible government becomes harder to maintain the larger (in population) and more heterogeneous (ethnically, culturally and even economically) a country is. Feedback takes longer to reach the government; local protest is easier to extinguish and marginalize; problems can stay unnoticed for longer while everyone is watching federal politics or pretending it doesn't need to concern them. This doesn't mean that we should try to break up states willy-nilly; Ukraine would probably have been a lot less successful if it entered the war in two pieces, and a divided Britain would be missing at least some of its current influence. But descriptively, it seems like a good predictor for success/failure of states where it would otherwise be surprising. Many small countries (including ones I thought well-governed, like Israel) went draconian on COVID restrictions early on, but quickly let go once they realized it wasn't sustainable or particularly well-advised. Being small and not overly bureaucratized, they reversed their policies without much trouble. Meanwhile, China's government can afford to live in the clouds for a while with its GDP, and the US, even as its government rightly changed course, is struggling to keep significant parts of its population on board.

This also means that success stories like Singapore, Israel, Estonia, Switzerland are perhaps less impressive than they look like -- sure, they've been going the right way, but they also had an easier time finding and following it. I've been joking that whoever loses the 2022 Sweden elections should get to rule Germany as a consolation prize, but in reality they would soon be suffering from the same problems that plague German politics. I'm afraid having Lee Kuan Yew preside over China won't be much better.

Obviously, this also means that the EU should be blown down to its role from the 1990s, but I doubt anyone commenting on this blog would disagree with that.

165 more comments...

Ready for more?