Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dunstan Ramsay's avatar

I'm sympathetic, but I think this essay wants for a distinction between private- and public-sector unions. The immoral behavior you cite (garbage piling up, schools closing) seems so bad precisely because in these cases unions are standing in the way of the delivery of public goods that, in lots of places though not all, it's government's responsibility to provide.

Public sector unions, of course, clash with the entire concept of a union, and a lot of fair-minded liberals and progressives seem to have been snowed into making a category error here. The government is not a capitalist enterprise expropriating surplus value provided by public-sector workers. In a democracy, organized labor in the public sector is organizing against.... their fellow citizens.

Expand full comment
Christopher Renner's avatar

"Direct redistribution does not seem to inspire this kind of entitlement among its beneficiaries"

Dude, you need to get out and meet some welfare recipients.

Expand full comment
129 more comments...

No posts