Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lasagna's avatar

Great article (or conversation, whatever) as always.

I had two negative thoughts, though:

1. I don’t want to hold people accountable. I’m sick of holding everyone accountable. It’s become witch burning by another name. Just state your case and stop gloating over your fallen enemies.

2. Yes, everyone means “Twitter reflects only the opinions of elite urban rich liberals” when they say “Twitter isn’t real life”. The first formulation, though, is infinitely more meaningful than the second - the thing they “really mean” is more important than what they’re actually saying.

From the standpoint of someone not on social media at all but forced to read it because guys like you link to it constantly: these interactions that you treasure seem to be deeply infected by this. Twitter never ventures outside of a bizarre Twitter only Overton window except to argue about the window itself and its fairness. That matters.

I’m at a bar and drinking, so yeah. Not sure this is making sense. Anyway, love the Substack.

Expand full comment
GG's avatar

To be honest RH, I love your blog but I had to unsubscribe from your Twitter. Your blog has a dry, matter of fact style, while Twitter jumps straight to moral/aesthetic judgements. Not that your blog doesn't moralize, it's just that you tend to lay the facts out first and let readers connect the dots.

For example, in the "Russia as the Great Satan" blog post, you never actually say that homosexuality is disgusting, but we can deduce it. But on Twitter, you'll skip the subtlety and go straight to complaining about gay airline stewards forcing you to wear masks.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts