134 Comments
User's avatar
Zack's avatar

As someone who grew up in an immigrant community and married into one, I think from a policy perspective there needs to be some boring limiting principles. I.e, maybe total % of population born outside the US, plus some sort of metrics around low vs high skilled immigrants.

Nativists have never been able to articulate a philosophical principle around nativism because there really isn’t one. In that way, the turn to “preferences” is refreshingly honest. That said, I think MOST people would agree that bringing in 1 billion non-Americans right now would be bad, regardless of their composition (as a hypothetical). With that context, the non US-born population is at all time highs, surpassing its late 19th-century record. There’s a reason why opposition to immigrants was an animating issue during times of high immigration and not, for instance, in the 1950s.

Articulating some sort of limiting principles in a way that appeals to both the restrictionists and the progressives (for whom this issue is not a priority) will be critical for achieving reform. Otherwise it will remain a hobby horse for the worst sorts of demagogues. Denmark has made meaningful progress here, and other western countries should take note.

Unknown's avatar

It is indeed a hobby horse for the worst sort of demagogues and that is not going change.

The problem is not the "lack of articulated principles", the problem is what people say is not what people want. For example average Joe want his brother to be able to bring his girlfriend to this country but does not like Indians and Chinese at his workplace. Farmer McDonalds wants the labor on H2 but is opposed to Mexicans coming through marriage. Christian Richard wants Christian converts to be able to come to USA but not the Turban wearing Sikhs and so on.

So in some sense everyone wants some sort of immigrants and wants to portray other sorts as evil.

Some want high skilled but not as high skilled as Indians or Chinese. Some want students but not workers. Some want workers but not students. Some think it is to be linked with skills where as some think family is more important.

There is no real principle that all these people could agree to but nearly all of them have some or other sort of "pro-immigrant" stance except for the bottom of the barrel nativists.

Mr. Fisk's avatar

OK, so if nativism cannot be justified philosophically, does this apply everywhere? Do you keep the same energy when either India or Israel's immigration policies are brought up? Should these countries feel obligated to bring in high skilled immigrants of every background?

Zack's avatar

Of course it's the same everywhere. It's just that nobody is trying to move to India. Lots of people move to Israel, and they have a national concept as an explicitly Jewish country (controversial, obviously).

I'm also not saying we have to bring high skilled immigrants from everywhere! We have two political tribes that speak different moral languages. The left sees immigration as a social justice issue - with residency in the US as a form of aid that we owe to the global poor. The right has two flavors - a nativist right whose primary concern is cultural affinity, and a small remnant of the business right which is mainly focused on economic contribution. We need to make arguments in the language that resonates with people.

Panini's avatar

The US already has quite stringent filters, quotas, and limits for legal immigration. And this is about 100 times true for Indians, because of the country-specific immigration caps. What other "limiting principle" are you looking for, and why is the current status quo not adequate?

Note that I'm talking specifically about legal immigration. The US has not had anything resembling open borders since the WW1 era. And illegal immigration is a consequence of poor law enforcement and lack of political will, not because a "limiting principle" is missing.

Melissa James's avatar

I think if you had written this piece during a period of history when illegal immigration was low, I would have thought it appropriate and thoughtful, and mostly agreed with it (Though I think you do yourself a disservice to ignore people complaining about relatively recent developments with the abuse and expansion of H1B visa to hire skilled foreign workers in tech mostly to undercut American salaries, because they’re cheaper and have directly harmed the job market for tech workers. These tech workers are complaining about the immigration of “skilled” Indian workers precisely because they tend on average to be lower skilled than themselves, but also because they are being directly economically harmed. It would be worth acknowledging that many people do have real or perceived economic complaints even about legal immigration that are not based on racial bias. Even if you think they’re wrong to be worried, you should acknowledge the fear is based on immediate economic concerns, rather than other bases.)

But either way it’s hard to write this piece ranting about people who hate legal immigration being bad when it comes on the heels of long periods of sky high illegal immigration, and public sentiment on illegal immigration is very different, with most people thinking it is distinctly bad and wanting to slow it down and stop it. When it comes to immigration, it matters a lot which specific question is asked, and about the only area with broad support is the question of legal, skilled immigration. The anti-immigration parties are getting the support they’re getting precisely because elite party members have ignored and failed to address majority positions on controlling illegal immigration, and study after study have shown that (at least 2-4 years ago), the deepest misalignment between the general population and elected officials was their position on immigration and elected officials stance against broadly making serious efforts to control illegal immigration.

So yes, most people support legal skilled immigration. But your piece inexplicably ignores that the current noise and volume on immigration and support for anti-immigration parties comes from a majority desire to make it a controlled and orderly process, and a response against the broad idea and ethos behind decriminalizing illegal immigration (as many 2020 Democratic candidates endorsed).

Richard Hanania's avatar

Have you been following the news the last year or two? We have an administration that stopped illegal immigration and is seeking to shut down skilled immigration too to the greatest extent it can.

Melissa James's avatar

Yes, illegal immigration is currently mostly stopped, but the spigot being currently stopped doesn’t address the reality of the spigot having been wide open for a large enough period of time that there are currently huge populations of illegal immigrants recently arrived and how to address this. It doesn’t alter the fact that the current landscape on immigration sentiment is impacted by the reality of the presence of huge volumes of illegal immigration and the reality that foreign born population % is at an all-time historic high, in large part due to illegal immigration, and that this reality and efforts to address this (good, bad and ugly) are dominating immigration sentiment and discourse everywhere.

Person Online's avatar

Also, we all know that if a Democrat gets back in the White House, illegal immigration will resume unchecked. The threat isn't actually gone, just temporarily delayed.

Joseph's avatar

how much immigration is too much?

* Should we allow immigration at all? If so, how much?

* Who should qualify, and by what criteria?

* Should nationality matter? If so, which countries should be favored or excluded?

* At what immigrant share of the population does immigration become a problem?

Then, explain what bad outcomes you think will occur, or have already occurred, when immigration exceeds your limits. Finally, what would your immigration policy cost us economically, socially, and politically?

Melissa James's avatar

To do justice to your post would require a several page long policy paper or essay response, and I’m sorry to tell you I won’t be doing that. I think you can probably guess broadly what directions I lie in from my previous posts. Strict limits and strong enforcement of illegal immigration, with narrow exceptions for classic and robust asylum cases and the provision of temporary protected status when appropriate with an eye towards it being genuinely temporary, unless there are severe extenuating circumstances. Legal immigration I would generally support expanding, but not at the present moment because immigration levels have been too high for social cohesion and robust economic benefits, so probably revisit expansion in five or perhaps ten years. But I’d focus again on skilled immigration, regardless of country of origin or nationality, with an eye towards increasing the supply of professions we are short on (physicians are one such profession but there are plenty of others, especially teachers come to mind). And allowing for family, but narrowly. As for citizenship, I think I’d take a Swiss eye towards it and offer it for those who demonstrate integration (which is a different bar than abandoning or repudiating one’s culture of origin, which isn’t at all necessary) and a genuine appreciation for the country they are adopting.

There are plenty of coherent policy proposals which would meaningfully steer the country towards these goals. I’d be pretty happy with most of them I’d wager, and am perfectly willing to compromise if it meant making meaningful progress on passing immigration legislation and bringing this country back to a well-functioning system.

John's avatar

Exactly. This article represents a tone-deaf position on the real issues at hand.

The abuse of the immigration system by bad actors (on all sides) has put immense pressure on the system's ability to produce effective results. To call people who have been cast aside by dissociative global interests 'racist' because they still depend on their immediate environment, is terribly disingenuous.

True nativists are low-hanging fruit and not interesting. Richard does not address the real issues that, I believe, are animating the energy around an increased skepticism toward immigration.

Unknown's avatar

> relatively recent developments with the abuse and expansion of H1B visa to hire skilled foreign workers in tech mostly to undercut American salaries, because they’re cheaper and have directly harmed the job market for tech workers

This opinion is not even remotely facts based. Tech is the only industry where salaries have increased fare more rapidly than any other sector. This sector has grown faster than nearly every other sector giving advantage to Americans. This is because of F1 and H1B visas for which American natives should be deeply thankful to Indians and Chinese.

H1B visa is one of the most restrictive visa where Indians and Chinese are trapped into a decades long greencard queue but these wonderful people continue to work.

Americans should ideally write songs about these people and be VERY VERY grateful

Carol Fletez's avatar

I don't like the part of skilled immigrants for the tech sector because of many things: Indians bring their own prejudiced attitudes by importing their caste system which adds to already prejudice we've been grappling with the for some time. In addition when they stay and cripple the family reunification processes for us citizens to bring here their spouses and children while they import total families who bring more of the activities we don't allow like fmd to the detriment to society and our culture.

One H1B person in Nevada brought in 96 relatives. Skilled workers should be limited to the initial time of the contract and forced to return home and wait at least three years before they can apply to emigrate.

By overwhelming the immigration system my niece had to wait two years for her fiance from France to come here,!

ragnarrahl's avatar

"One H1B person in Nevada brought in 96 relatives. "

source?

Carol Fletez's avatar

Where Does the "96 Family Members" Concept Come From?

When figures like "96" or "100" family members are cited in immigration debates, they refer to an indirect multi-generational chain occurring over many decades, rather than a single person sponsoring everyone at once. " My main point with this is that it should ONLY be immediate spouse and minor children. No siblings and no parents. In our neighborhood a family brought over their elderly father who spoke no English but managed by lying to put him in public housing (immigrants are not allowed to use these facilities).

Unknown's avatar

You are clearly not familiar with the immigration law.

Carol Fletez's avatar

It was published elsewhere and I will find it - Jagdish Patel came to the U.S. from India in 1968 and eventually sponsored his wife and 6 siblings. Their descendants include doctors, dentists and a venture capitalist. This is the face of family-based migration, which President Trump wants to limit.

ragnarrahl's avatar

so one person brought 7, and then reproduction happened among Americans. Can you see how that's not what it sounded like you were claiming?

Cubicle Farmer's avatar

Yes, they are bad people, for two reasons.

Firstly, to the extent they are intellectually dishonest, that's bad in general.

Secondly, if they think the juice of ethnic homogeneity is worth the squeeze of ethnic cleansing (with the inevitable violence and disruption that is entailed), that's a bad tradeoff, and they're bad people for preferring it.

Dave's avatar
Oct 7Edited

The motivations for restricting immigration from Trump and his goon administration (headed by Stephen Miller who thinks, talks and acts like a Nazi) is pure racism of the worst kind.

The vilification of Haitians, with the repulsive and ridiculous “they are eating your pets” bullcrap….to “shithole countries” …to calling some immigrant “animals”….to “When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best... They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists.” ….to “You know, now a murderer, I believe this, it’s in their genes,” Trump said on the Hugh Hewitt radio show, amid one rant against immigrants, by far the most popular target of hate for his fans. “And we got a lot of bad genes in our country right now,” he added.” ….to Trump’s claims that immigrants are “poisoning the blood” of the U.S….and on and on and on.

The most glaring evidence of pure racist animus that is the basis for Trump’s actions concerning immigration is when he cut off ALL refugee immigration (almost all non-white people who have been vetted for more than a year, sometimes several years) but, FAST TRACKED white Afrikaners (5,000) with the absurd and false accusation of them being victims of “genocide”.

Mr. Haninia asks the question “Are immigration Restrictionists Bad People?”…

In the Trump administration the answer is unequivocally YES!!!

These are racist scumbags to the core headed up by the Racist-in-chief, Donald Trump and his right-hand Joseph Goebbels Stephen Miller.

Peter S. Shenkin's avatar

1. Personal note: I'm a Jew from the Bronx. My experience is that if I live where everybody is like me, I get bored. If I live where nobody is like me, I get lonesome.

2. I'm also a scientist. And yes, I think that those with special skills, not only in science, but in the arts, too, should be shoo-ins for immigration. (My wife was Lebanese and a jewelry designer. She gained US citizenship at least partly on the strength of her portfolio and recommendation letters, presented during her interview.)

3. On the other hand, the large increase in trucking cost is due not only to fuel shortages but to driver shortages, since about 200K truck drivers with valid work permits have now been forbidden to drive because they don't speak English well enough. Anthony Bourdain pointed out that the restaurants he worked in in NY could not have survived without an army of low paid and hard working Hispanics doing all kinds of work behind the scenes. The slaves built the cotton industry. The Chinese and Irish built the railroads. The Germans contributed the largest contribution to our blood and fought with us against their country of ancestral origin. French soldiers and sailors arriving during the American revolution reported surprise over the observation that about 1/4 of the Patriot forces consisted of blacks, many of whom were runaway slaves.

4. Those on the right who oppose immigration are often the same ones complaining that our birth rate is down and we are going to experience a population deficit. I don't have statistics on this, but my guess is that our population growth in the past has been significantly assisted by immigration. And those immigrants and their descendents have fought for our country.

5. Recall that in 1987, under Reagan, Federal law granted amnesty to immigrants who had been here some length of time. However, the law also made it impossible to vet or reject new immigrants applying for work. It actually became illegal for someone applying for a job in America to be asked whether they had a legal right to work here. And there were virtually no penalties for hiring illegal immigrants. To this day, as far as I know, meatpacking companies who knowingly built a workforce consisting almost entirely of illegal immigrants have never been prosecuted. (If you know otherwise, I'd like to know.) The law was built to be flauted, and that is largely responsible for the situation we are in now. On the other hand, to his credit, Reagan said "Nobody can become an Englishman, but anybody can become an American." I didn't vote for him, but I admire that sentiment.

Peter S. Shenkin's avatar

As a coda, populism can work both ways. Here's Merle Haggard, with "The Immigrant":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6UfoWdRcU8

Daniel Sz's avatar

I think an important point is that the “homogeneity” argument is particularly hard to make for the US and other settler colonial societies like Australia or Canada. Heritage American discourse is silly because on some level all Americans are immigrants and in fact nearly every prominent rightoid has immigrants in their families including Trump, Vance and Rufo.

This type of homogeneity argument makes much more sense in places like Japan where I think something genuinely would be lost if it stopped being majority ethnic Japanese. Arguably countries like France have become irreversibly worse places due to immigration. Ironically European leftists often use “nation of immigrants” style discourse to justify mass immigration, confusing their countries history with America’s. It’s almost like European leftists want to LARP as if they lived in a US style settler colonial state and American rightoids want to LARP as if they lived in a European ethnostate, all while ironically centering a large part of their political identity around disdain towards the continent they are attempting to emulate.

Leslie MacMilla's avatar

Or it could be just a case of pulling up the drawbridge once you are safely across the moat. An American, Canadian, or Australian "nativist" doesn't have to care that he is being hypocritical as all get out. Most people are perfectly happy being hypocrites.

Ebenezer's avatar

Calling it hypocritical seems lazy. A better metaphor than a drawbridge might be a lifeboat: If too many people get in, it's gonna sink, so you have to stop somewhere.

I actually just wrote a note on why I don't think it is hypocritical to call for immigration restriction even as a very recent immigrant: https://substack.com/@ebenezer1/note/c-355513249

Leslie MacMilla's avatar

OK, the lifeboat metaphor isn't lazy. It's just wrong. More immigration doesn't sink the lifeboat. Among the immigrants will be boat-builders who will transform it into an aircraft carrier, just as European immigration did to Canada and the US. That said, the point you make in your Substack is a good one, not really lifeboat-ish, though.

I don't think there is anything wrong with hypocrisy, is my point. The indigenous people of North American and AusNZ would argue that Europeans did far more damage to their cultures than Indians/Chinese could ever do to ours. That needn't stop us from asking, "So? Your point?" If we want to stop immigration now -- I don't think we should, for RH's reasons -- we can shrug off the accusation of hypocrisy with a simple, "That was then, with them. This is now, with us."

Douglas Levene's avatar

“I don’t care if you personally like such individuals or want them as neighbors. But to want fewer of them in the country reflects a diseased mindset.” — Hear, hear!

Carol Fletez's avatar

What about when they bring with them the diseased mindset of CASTE! AND ADD to existing prejudice by adding more? I assure you they don't bring more accepting concepts of the place of women for example

Ghatanathoah's avatar

How exactly is the diseased mindset of caste going to harm existing Americans? Hinduism isn't a prostheletyzing religion. Hindus aren't going around trying to get Americans to join lower castes. You are either born into a caste or you aren't. No non-Indian Americans are born into castes, so who cares whether some Indian American believes in it?

Carol Fletez's avatar

It is not that you are proselytizing but that you treat others by the caste systems which apparently define how you treat others NOT in your caste or women or people of color because the castes discriminate based on race as well as name. I have witnessed a certified DBA Indian woman in tech be forced to tears by the way a man talked to her in my presence. She explained to our manager the cruel man was of a higher caste. And that is not the only time I have witnessed such behavior. SInce they both were here in H1B visa status even a complaint to the contracting company (an INDIAN ONE) did nothing; our discrimination laws did not apply but the man was eventually fired for talking like that to a US citizen. DIsrespectful totally.

Unknown's avatar

Caste system is 100% consistent with the values of America and Individual liberty. People have a right of association with like minded people and including those who have all sort of caste identities.

> castes discriminate based on race as well as name

It depends on what you refer to as "discrimination". A worksplace harassment is just workplace harassment to be government by existing rules. Just because the victim claims it is due to "caste" it need not be so. White women play they "gender" card all the time at workplaces but I do not think American men are a problem. Also, given Hindus are super minority in USA, a person can easily switch a job and work for a Muslim instead. This actually imposes a penalty on caste practicing Hindus. Which is all the reason for more Hindus in United States as their caste identity becomes irrelevant in this country.

> man was eventually fired for talking like that to a US citizen.

That sounds like discrimination against that man. There is no law against "disrespecting US citizens".

There is a good chance you are on some meds.

Cubicle Farmer's avatar

I'm not sure I really believe that though. People who choose to come to a new society are already signalling they have a greater than average acceptance of the values of that society even if they are not "completely on board" (and our society doesn't even agree with *itself* so what does "completely on board" even entail?) Secondly, the values of the new society tend to rub off further, especially on the children. (tension between conservative first generation immigrants who want the kids to stick to the old ways and their children who embrace the new ways of the new country is practically a staple of fiction).

Yes, assimilation can fail for various reasons (see Muslims in Europe), but that's not what I see happening in North America. That photo of the Indian students cheering at the Texas football game... I mean how much more assimilated can you be? What's the real ask? (the real, usually unstated, ask is "don't be brown", which is RH's point).

Carol Fletez's avatar

Unless you have worked in the TECH community you ahve not experienced any of the caste system effects in person. I and co-workers have. Men speaking disrespectfully to and about others not of their caste and refusing to work with them. Not to mention their actions around women from India or USA citizens. Or refusing to hire US citizens because 'Indians from 'XYZ- fill in the blanks) deserve to do this work because we are better and have the rights to take your job". Judging others by the degree their skin color is 'whiter' and where they come from in INDIA!

Cubicle Farmer's avatar

Wait until you hear what the native born workers get up to sometimes.

Some people are jerks! Full story at 11.

Unknown's avatar

> Men speaking disrespectfully to and about others not of their caste and refusing to work with them

It is all your accusations and you are in no position to tell how others think. You are probably one of the MAGS losers who are in general a loser and has learned to blame it on caste practicing "men" as if women do not practice caste. Also caste has nothing to do with skin color.

Carol Fletez's avatar

What about when they bring with them the diseased mindset of CASTE! AND ADD to existing prejudice by adding more? I assure you they don't bring more accepting concepts of the place of women for example

Color Me Skeptical's avatar

The U.S. already has a caste system. It is one based on race, with darker-skinned people in the bottom caste.

Have you read the book “Caste?” It explains this reality quite well.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caste:_The_Origins_of_Our_Discontents

Carol Fletez's avatar

Yes and as I describe above it is precisely that same mindset they bring.

Color Me Skeptical's avatar

My point is, the caste system is already in the U.S. The Indian immigrants aren’t bringing anything new with respect to it.

Color Me Skeptical's avatar

The people who are complaining about Indian immigration are indeed losers who want to their personal failures on immigration, instead of looking at their own failings and poor choices.

Unknown's avatar

The word "caste" itself comes from west, where Portuguese invented to to describe something they did not understand and clearly neither do you.

If you think there is a "caste" problem all you have to do is start your own company where you hire all the "victims of caste" who will gladly work for you and destroy the competition.

Most often people are just losers and then they blame their failures on external factors to feel good about themselves. It is a coping mechanism.

Thoughtful India's avatar

Is there any evidence for this outside of hysteria by left wing NGOs?

James Egel's avatar

Ironically, the presence of Elon Musk in America with the resulting poorly thought out DOGE cuts is an argument against allowing skilled immigrants into this country.

Argentus's avatar

"There’s an unstated assumption here that most Americans agree with nativists."

I think a very large chunk and possibly an outright majority prefer homogeneity. However, this truth contains nuances that nativists aren't dealing with. It doesn't mean what they think it means.

One is that a preference for homogeneity is often not a preference for some kind of ancient "blood and soil" thing but is just status quo bias and anti-uncertainty. Things changing means that a person's familiarity and position may become more tenuous. A legible terrain is one they can navigate. Someone who is confident in their capacity to navigate uncertainty and to learn how to map new territories cares less about the environment staying the same. Most people are not actually upset about living next door to Mexicans because of some deep affinity for whiteness or being WASP or whatever. They are concerned about what the Mexicans may mean for the legibility of the territory. When they manage to navigate the new circumstances (and they pretty much always do), they just stop caring about Mexicans because they are now a legible part of the territory.

Two is that even if people dislike Mexicans/whoever as such, it does not mean that they put this considerably high on their prioritization list. Lots of people care about abortion one way or the other, but the number of people who are consistently abortion #1 issue voters (either for or against) is not very large. I'm from the rural South. I know a ton of old people who just generically dislike black people. And almost none of these old people make that their #1 or often even top ten things they think or care about on any given day. They will mutter a racial slur because some dude is blasting hip hop at the gas station and then forget about it. They will also go on daily tirades about the price of canned goods or spend hours consuming Fox content about what people with blue hair are doing in San Francisco.

In other words, these preferences for status quo and some amount of generic distaste does not translate into wide enthusiastic support for social engineering projects to preserve the white majority with jack booted thug tactics or doing things that tank the economy.

Lucidus's avatar

What’s the evidence that illegal immigration is good? The trades are heavily impacted by illegal immigration. When a Mexican comes to town illegally for example, they charge much less for their services, driving down the wages for natives. This is why most southerners don’t like illegal immigration, because it actually impacts their businesses and economies, whereas in the north, they are more so only impacted by legal immigration.

Cubicle Farmer's avatar

The article is not about illegal immigration though.

Lucidus's avatar

Yes, but it conveniently leaves out that most of these extreme positions arise when exposed to the illegal kind. I know some people just hate it in general no matter what, and he makes the argument against that. Fine. That’s not the problem.

Melissa James's avatar

I definitely agree with this. Illegal immigration is the elephant in the room which is so large it’s crazy he doesn’t at least dedicate a paragraph to stating it’s a different issue with different preferences but is not the subject of this piece. Because large majorities of people in all countries, including the US, do not like illegal immigration and have very serious issues with how, say, Biden, let in huge numbers.

Cubicle Farmer's avatar

I think you are being entirely too charitable to the legal immigration restrictionists. They know what they're asking for and why. They say so! Again, that's what the piece is about, not what you think it should be about.

Ghatanathoah's avatar

Wages are only being driven down if you look at the wages of the service provider in isolation. If you look at all Americans in the town, their wages are effectively being driven up because services are now more affordable for them than they used to be. If services are cheaper that means that your wages are going further because you can spend the extra money you previously would have spent on services on something else. Basically one small subset of Americans' wages are being driven down while the wages of all other Americans are being driven up. Why does that one subset count for more?

Leslie MacMilla's avatar

You are correct and that's a good question.

People hurt by any economic change, whether by deliberate policy or not, are always more aware of their losses, which are obvious and quantifiable to them, than the larger community whose gains are diffuse and smaller per capita, even if larger in aggregate. It will not be as obvious to this larger group that their gains (even if they are aware of them) are due to immigration, as it will be to the small group with immigrant competitors who are perfectly aware that the arrival of an immigrant plumber pushed down the rates for plumbers like themselves.

People are usually more sensitive to (risk of) losses than they are to (chance of) gains. That's why only stupid people gamble. It's also why immigration policy is so hard to get right.

Peter S. Shenkin's avatar

I'm not sure why you are asking me this question. The only thing I said about illegal immigration is that Reagan's amnesty law made it virtually impossible for an employer to vet a new employee to make sure he was legal, and that was bad. I always viewed that part of the law as a gift to Republican business owners to get cheap labor through the back door.

I think every country needs an immigration policy — or at least mine does — and that the discussion should be mainly about what that policy should be. But right now, even legal immigrants are being barred from some forms of employment. The illegal immigrants who have entered since 1987 have lived and thrived here because of the brain-dead unenforceability of vetting the legality of job candidates enshrined in the Reagan amnesty bill.

Jay's avatar

It’s not the purpose of the USA to maximize GDP, or any economic measure, for that matter.

Nyc's avatar

He made the U.S. sound purely like an economic zone, and not an actual country.

Leslie MacMilla's avatar

As a white Canadian living in Canada, I think the United States is attracting a better class of Indian immigrant than we are, and the good ones we get are buffing their resumés to try to get from Canada into the United States. (Few become Canadian citizens.) It seems nuts to oppose immigration of skilled Indians into America when you consider what "highly skilled" means in your visa-granting process. In Canada, "highly skilled" mostly means passable fluency in English or French (not that many Indians want to settle in Quebec), with extra points for having a qualification like a medical or engineering degree under which they can't practice professionally in Canada anyway. Our Indian immigrants are Door-dash E-bike drivers and donut-shop counter-people. Their children might be successful strivers eventually but they bring their elderly parents over for free single-payer health care (and as informal child care) so the impact on the GDP, and GDP per capita, is unfortunately attenuated. But the impact on consumption of tax-funded health care is not.

Our immigration regime is more broken than yours, a fact I hope Canadian readers of your Substack keep in mind before they rag on Indian immigration to the only country in the world that matters.

Steve Sailer's avatar

There's nothing that adds more to the quality of American discourse than framing debates to appeal to a 6-year-old WWE fan: Who are the Good Guys? Who are Bad Guys?

Jeffrey Wernick's avatar

Rights precede government. If there is only one lesson we should learn from this anniversary year if we took the time to actually read carefully the Declaration of Independence is that fact. Rights precede government. And for the first hundred years, more or less, we had an open border as a consequence of that understanding that rights precede government. The omission in the Constitution of any role for the federal government in immigration but only naturalization was not an oversight but intentional. So yes, anyone who expects to enjoy an unalienable right yet deprive others of it is a bad person, IMO.

Argentus's avatar

Whaa? In what sense can there be anything called a "right" (that isn't just a fuzzy woo nonsense word) that isn't a) explicitly spelled out in some form and b) protected and enforced somehow. And at the point that it's spelled out and enforced, how is that not government?

Like the aspirational *idea* of rights precedes their explicit documentation and enforcement, but they do not exist as anything but ideals beforehand. And even this aspirational idea of rights is in no way universal or consistent across time and space.

*Edit*

I am a liberal, but this is a consistent liberal blind spot. This idea that human rights are *real* in the way that like gravity and math is real. They aren't. They are human defined and contingent on local circumstances (specifically usually health and stability of local institutions).

It often leads people to declaring that people must have things (housing, free speech, healthcare, education, whatever) without bothering to actually answer the boring question, "yes, but *how?*" (Let alone "why?")

Cubicle Farmer's avatar

I also thought Jeffrey's comment seemed confused.

1. What is a right, other than a "legal" right?

2. What "legal rights" are there without government?

Jeffrey Wernick's avatar

I suggest to either reread for comprehension the beginning of the Declaration of Independence or read it carefully if you have never done so.

Rights existed before governments did. Is your argument that if people are born into jurisdictions with the absence of government, that they have no rights? One thing are our natural rights. Another is the ability to protect and defend them.

Cubicle Farmer's avatar

"Is your argument that if people are born into jurisdictions with the absence of government, that they have no rights?"

I'm not making an argument, I'm turning that question around on you. (because I think it's the right question to ask, not because I'm trying to score points).

What does a "right" look like if there is no government or legal system to enforce it?

What *is* such a right?

What will these "rights" do for you in the state of nature?

If the answer is "nothing", then what is the meaning of the sentence "Rights existed before governments did"?

Why would it even be necessary for me to argue: "people born into jurisdictions with the absence of government have no rights", if these "rights" don't amount to anything? What would we be arguing about?

Also, I'm Canadian so what do I care what the DoI says? It seems to me that to be valid your argument should be portable across national boundaries.

Jeffrey Wernick's avatar

Let me try to keep this simple. The Constitution granted the federal government a limited set of enumerated rights. The Bill of Rights reasserts and reconfirmed that. What is not enumerated in the Constitution was left to the states and the people. The federal government was granted no right wrt immigration. Naturalization, yes. Immigration, no.

The federal power which now almost everyone takes for granted, was invented by the Supreme Court in 1889, the Chinese Exclusion Case. Not derived from any clause in the Constitution.

The Constitution was designed to be changed two ways. An amendment. Or a new convention. But a corrupt people who want their way even when they cannot get the consent of the people still want their way with as little consent as possible. Ergo, judicial fiat. Win the Congress. Select the judges. Change the constitution by controlling the courts. Getting judges to rewrite the Constitution and avoid the process delineated by the Constitution itself. An act of hubris. Vanity. And authoritarian. And most people are closet authoritarians. Some more overt than others.

Argentus's avatar

"Rights precede government." You did not add to this a qualification that meant "became common law was a thing in Anglo legal systems." But even if you did, common law (which is where the unenumerated rights you are talking about like as an example the general right to move around public spaces where you want without needing some kind of permit or permission) is a component of government.

"Unenumerated rights" as they existed in common law are not the same thing that Enlightenment philosophers like Thomas Jefferson meant by inalienable rights. Common law rights are rights that come from tradition and are enforced by more organic or ad hoc styles of governance. "Natural/inalienable/human" rights are magical woo things we supposedly got from a usually pretty deistic God that the Enlightenment liked.

Jeffrey Wernick's avatar

By your definition rights do not exist at all. Only privileges either conveyed or withheld by government. At their discretion. And your claim would also assert that the people who wrote the Constitution, voted to ratify the Constitution were all willing to surrender their personal sovereignty to the State. I think most liberals think that. Which is why I believe most, if not all liberals are authoritarians. They believe I am not a sovereign individual but an indentured servant to the State. Which is also why I am so amused at liberals calling Trump and Trumpers authoritarian. They should look in the mirror.

Unset's avatar

There is too much reductionism going on this article for it to have any utility. The situation in Europe cannot be conflated with the US. Athough I agree that there is nothing wrong with nativists there saying, we don't want to be minoritized in our thousand year homeland.

With respect to the US, how are you defining "nativist?" You really didn't, although you seem to lump into the category anyone who supports any rules or restrictions whatsoever on immigration.

Vivernu's avatar

"Nobody on the left cares that Denmark has taken a hard line on immigration, because it appears that they are doing it for technocratic or liberal reasons."

This isn't true. There's actually a perception at least decades old that Denmark is secretly racist. It's certainly not taken as seriously as how Le Pen or Orban etc. are treated but there are in fact criticisms of Denmark from the left/multiculturalists that they have secretly racist policies. I believe Denmark has a law that requires neighborhoods to be "majority western" and this is typically perceived to mean white.