Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Zack's avatar

As someone who grew up in an immigrant community and married into one, I think from a policy perspective there needs to be some boring limiting principles. I.e, maybe total % of population born outside the US, plus some sort of metrics around low vs high skilled immigrants.

Nativists have never been able to articulate a philosophical principle around nativism because there really isn’t one. In that way, the turn to “preferences” is refreshingly honest. That said, I think MOST people would agree that bringing in 1 billion non-Americans right now would be bad, regardless of their composition (as a hypothetical). With that context, the non US-born population is at all time highs, surpassing its late 19th-century record. There’s a reason why opposition to immigrants was an animating issue during times of high immigration and not, for instance, in the 1950s.

Articulating some sort of limiting principles in a way that appeals to both the restrictionists and the progressives (for whom this issue is not a priority) will be critical for achieving reform. Otherwise it will remain a hobby horse for the worst sorts of demagogues. Denmark has made meaningful progress here, and other western countries should take note.

Melissa James's avatar

I think if you had written this piece during a period of history when illegal immigration was low, I would have thought it appropriate and thoughtful, and mostly agreed with it (Though I think you do yourself a disservice to ignore people complaining about relatively recent developments with the abuse and expansion of H1B visa to hire skilled foreign workers in tech mostly to undercut American salaries, because they’re cheaper and have directly harmed the job market for tech workers. These tech workers are complaining about the immigration of “skilled” Indian workers precisely because they tend on average to be lower skilled than themselves, but also because they are being directly economically harmed. It would be worth acknowledging that many people do have real or perceived economic complaints even about legal immigration that are not based on racial bias. Even if you think they’re wrong to be worried, you should acknowledge the fear is based on immediate economic concerns, rather than other bases.)

But either way it’s hard to write this piece ranting about people who hate legal immigration being bad when it comes on the heels of long periods of sky high illegal immigration, and public sentiment on illegal immigration is very different, with most people thinking it is distinctly bad and wanting to slow it down and stop it. When it comes to immigration, it matters a lot which specific question is asked, and about the only area with broad support is the question of legal, skilled immigration. The anti-immigration parties are getting the support they’re getting precisely because elite party members have ignored and failed to address majority positions on controlling illegal immigration, and study after study have shown that (at least 2-4 years ago), the deepest misalignment between the general population and elected officials was their position on immigration and elected officials stance against broadly making serious efforts to control illegal immigration.

So yes, most people support legal skilled immigration. But your piece inexplicably ignores that the current noise and volume on immigration and support for anti-immigration parties comes from a majority desire to make it a controlled and orderly process, and a response against the broad idea and ethos behind decriminalizing illegal immigration (as many 2020 Democratic candidates endorsed).

132 more comments...

Ready for more?