I’ve called for immigration restrictionists to stop being selective socialists and be more honest about what is motivating them. At least one has taken my advice, as can be seen in this clip recently posted by Jonathan Keeperman that now has three million views.
Keeperman complains about those who say:
You are a moral reprobate for preferring homogeneity. That makes you a bad person. That is pathological for you to express those preferences. And moreover, it’s pathological and bad for you to pursue your political preferences or political policies to advance your preference for homogeneity.
Conservatives, in his view, used to accept pro-immigration arguments because the restaurants were good and their neighbors were nice people, but now they’ve come to the conclusion that “maybe actually my desire to preserve homogeneity is just fine.” Restrictionists have no need to explain their preferences to the Cato Institute beyond “I just prefer this actually.”
An Unusually Passionate Minority
There’s an unstated assumption here that most Americans agree with nativists. But they don’t. Polls over the decades consistently say that they think immigration is good for the country. In 2023, 68% said so, compared to only 27% who thought it was bad.
I’ve noticed a tendency of nativists to simply assume that most people agree with them, while acting like those who disagree on immigration are all lying or brainwashed. But I don’t think there’s a reason to think that preference falsification can come close to explaining results this lopsided.
Still, immigration remains a hot-button issue because a small minority has intense preferences. Alex Kustov has shown that, while strict restrictionists are usually nowhere near a majority of voters in Western countries, they tend to be deeply passionate about the topic, more likely to name immigration as the top issue facing their country. More cosmopolitan voters do not prioritize it nearly as much. Hence, Republicans make deportations and keeping foreigners out their main rallying cries to energize their base, while Democrats tend to mostly talk about other things. In Europe, right-wing populist parties will focus on this one issue and get a decent share of the vote, but other parties that organize around broader principles can still outvote them.
The vast majority of Americans either like the idea of their country welcoming new people in, or think that such decisions are best made from a technocratic perspective. The view that a preference for homogeneity should be the driving factor in immigration policy is a minority opinion. Which should win in a democracy: the majority, or the faction that is most attached to its position? Do we weigh people’s opinions by intensity? One could argue either way, but regardless, the nativist assumption that most people agree with them is not true.
My read of the left is that they’re not passionate about immigration. It’s a pretty low priority for them, but they will radicalize when they see restrictionists who appear to be motivated by racism. Nobody on the left cares that Denmark has taken a hard line on immigration, because it appears that they are doing it for technocratic or liberal reasons. This is different from Trump, Orban, or Le Pen, for whom restrictionism is seen as part of a general fascist orientation. The point here is that if you want to talk about intensity of preferences, you have to stop and consider how many people really hate racism, which explains why far-right parties in Europe are so often not accepted into ruling coalitions.
Judge People by the Impacts of Their Positions
Regardless, none of this answers the question we started with: are immigration restrictionists bad people?
I would say yes, if they don’t want more Indians. Opposing low-skill immigrants or those who create more cultural difficulties can be rooted in innocent, pro-social motivations. But being opposed to high-skill immigration generally cannot be. Usually, when it comes to moral judgment, the issue is not which preferences we have, but how we act on them.
I dislike women having tattoos. If that’s just a personal preference regarding who to date or socialize with, that’s not something anyone gets passionate about. People will sometimes judge a race preference when it comes to dating, but they’re wrong to do so, and as long as you don’t feel the need to shout it from the rooftops, others will leave you alone to partner up with whoever you want.
In contrast, if my preference led me to demand that people with tattoos be banned from my town, or taxed at much higher rates, others would judge me harshly for this, as they should. A preference is not a carte blanche to treat others however we feel like. It’s what we do or advocate for based on our preferences that matters.
Restricting immigration means excluding people from living in the country of their choice. That’s a pretty extreme step, and inflicts a major harm on them. Even if you think the job of policy is only to look out for one’s own fellow citizens, Keeperman is acknowledging that he doesn’t care if lowering immigration reduces American living standards, since the focus of his rant was Indians. There’s always a hiding-of-the-ball aspect to this, where nativists will talk about “GDP” in order to make the costs of restrictionism as abstract as possible. Hence, they will say, “I want to cut immigration, even if it reduces GDP,” but will never say “I want to cut immigration, even if my children become poorer as a result.” The latter would make the tradeoffs more concrete.
When it comes to skilled immigration, then, the restrictionist “preference for homogeneity” means that, because people have a different phenotype or speak a different language at home, you want to take away their opportunities to improve their lives while also harming the future of your own country, and human progress more generally. This is before even getting into the gleeful cruelty many restrictionists regularly display.
If you’re uncomfortable around Indians, no law will force you to invite them to your house. Yes, anti-discrimination laws still exist, but people nonetheless are able to form communities that are practically all white. Indians ask nothing from you but to be able to work, innovate, and contribute to the economy.
Yellapragada Subbarow came to America and helped develop the drugs that produced the first successful remissions of childhood leukemia. Here’s what happened to the survival rate of that disease and other childhood cancers over time as a result.
More recently, Vinod Balachandran led a team that developed a personalized mRNA vaccine to treat pancreatic cancer. One can list an endless number of immigrants who have clearly saved American lives.
I don’t care if you personally like such individuals or want them as neighbors. But to want fewer of them in the country reflects a diseased mindset. It’s not a matter of just having more medical researchers; those who simply help grow the economy indirectly contribute to scientific research by creating larger markets and more money that can go toward research and development.
Go ahead and set aside any concern with fairness to outsiders. Your fellow Americans mostly want to live in a country where the economy is growing, living standards increase, and diseases are being cured. If your policy position is “my grandchildren can die sooner, as long as I maximize the percentage of whites” — and make no mistake, this is what opposition to H-1B visas means — it’s not the preference itself that is the issue, but your deranged value system.
Why Restrictionists Abandon Reason
To be sure, nativists try to come up with more rational sounding arguments for their views. I’ve written a series of articles deconstructing them one by one. See my pieces against higher-order race realism and the silly idea of “ethnic niches,” and my conversations with Amy Wax. These positions usually involve grasping at straws. You need to argue for uncertain impacts that would have to be truly disastrous in order to outweigh the risks of keeping even a single Jensen Huang or Elon Musk out of the country, much less larger groups of talented individuals. As I wrote in January of last year:
The most important point to stress from my perspective is that the costs of restricting high-skilled immigration are absolutely massive. You may worry about cultural change or other things, but a single Jensen Huang or Elon Musk can carry a lot of dead weight. As of October, Nvidia’s market cap was around $3.5 trillion. By way of comparison, all US spending on federal welfare programs was $1.2 trillion in 2022. Nothing in Huang’s family background indicates that they would have been let into the country under a system that only sought proven geniuses, as some restrictionists say they favor. If one wants to take all the human and physical capital assets of some of the most successful companies in the US and toss them into the ocean, they need to have an incredibly compelling reason.
Nativists seem to understand all of this at some level. They’re always reminding us that they’re not bad people, which is a pretty clear sign of a guilty conscience. There is also a constant need to construct their message in a way that avoids the natural implications of what they’re saying. GDP replaces concrete discussions about wealth, affordability, and a longer life expectancy. So much of their rhetoric centers around avoiding explicitly saying that they prefer whites, with euphemisms such as “Heritage American,” “high-trust society,” and “preference for homogeneity.”
Everyone of course tries to present their ideas in the best possible light. But because the root ideas are so indefensible, you see a lot more incoherence and many more euphemisms among restrictionists than those of other political persuasions. Nearly every argument that they make against low-skilled immigration — welfare use, crime, etc — suggests being more open to high-skilled immigration, yet only when forced into a corner will they bite the bullet and say that they only have preferences, not reasons. Nativists will likewise argue that they don’t care about GDP, and then complain about immigration’s effect on home prices or the labor market.
It’s remarkable how often these people demand an exemption from the normal rules of debate and rational discourse. How often do you see someone commenting about politics and saying “I don’t owe you an explanation”? Keeperman’s job is to explain his views to people! Yes, no one is interested in an explanation of why you prefer pizza to hot dogs, or why you chose your wife. But when you are in the political arena advocating policy positions that affect other people’s lives, you are generally expected to justify your views.
Nativists never shy away from providing reasons when it comes to groups that use welfare and commit crimes at high rates. As soon as the topic turns to Indians, however, they’re reduced to declaring that they have no use for your bugman reliance on facts and logic. And one can understand why. Rufo and Keeperman trying to explain the basis of their views was met by universal scorn across X outside the right-wing bubble, even among people who in other contexts are with them on DEI. The pro-immigration side can talk about improving health, longevity, national greatness, and scientific progress, along with basic moral principles like fairness, equality, and merit. The nativists have to ramble about spelling bees and fullbacks at keggers, and the subjective preferences of the most hateful and least productive members of society. Conservatives’ big idea this week is that “no real American studies for the spelling bee,” which wouldn’t even matter if true, and is contradicted by generations of cartoon and sitcom episodes anyway.
No wonder they’re so hostile to reason! The nativists are clearly embarrassed by their own arguments, as they should be.
These ideas aren’t just bad on their own merits; they’re strikingly inconsistent with what conservatives say they believe in other contexts. In The Atlantic, Jonathan Chait notes that while talk of merit was central to anti-DEI messaging, conservatives now treat it as a dirty word, as they assert that identitarian preferences matter more than objective standards, individual liberty, or the good of society as a whole. The fight against wokeness has achieved successes because it has rational arguments on its side, and can appeal to those outside the right-wing echo chamber. Organizations composed largely of moderate and liberal academics like FIRE and Heterodox Academy were able to make common cause with conservatives. We don’t see anything similar happening with the anti-immigration movement, and that is no accident. This is a reason for optimism, as in the long run ideas that can appeal to smart people are the ones that tend to have an advantage.
I’ve defended those who want to build all-white enclaves, taking the position that they should be left alone to live how they want. Certainly, these people are much more racist than your typical nativist, who doesn’t sacrifice for his preferences to anywhere near the same extent. But they are not hurting anyone, and that is what in the end matters. You might suspect that if members of Return to the Land had more power they would force their views on others, but we’re a long way from ever getting to that point, and people’s liberty generally shouldn’t be restricted based on theoretical concerns about what they might do in the future. The nativists, in contrast, are powerful, and support a concrete policy agenda that would make the world worse off.
It has likewise never bothered me to know that racism often motivates libertarian economic views and opposition to DEI. People can be right for the wrong reasons. Nativism, in contrast, combines bad motivations and disastrous impacts on the world.
The most honest restrictionists are the ones who are openly racist. But while they should be credited for their honesty, it is difficult to find other positive qualities that describe their views. I’m not saying I wouldn’t be friends with such a person, but I do consider restrictionism to be a character flaw, depending on how far one wants to go. If you want me to be more specific, I’ll say that to oppose a massive increase in the number of skilled workers coming into the US can’t be justified by any human value system that is worthy of respect. To go beyond the natural status quo bias that most people have and want fewer H-1B and F-1 visas is of course worse.
You don’t have to even care about foreigners to appreciate the wisdom of being pro-immigration. Simply having an enlightened view of the interests of your fellow citizens should alone take you at the very least toward supporting a world of open borders for educated professionals. If you don’t get there, something has gone terribly wrong in terms of your reasoning ability or moral judgment. Maybe having more Indian doctors can help us figure out what’s wrong with you.
This post is sponsored by Mechanize. AI alignment is perhaps the most important issue of our time, and if you’re interested in being part of that effort, Mechanize is hiring software engineers at a base salary of $300K-$400K/year, plus substantial bonuses. They also have openings for other positions, including Recruiter ($200K). Here is their website, and you can apply here. If you apply, make sure to use the links provided here so I can receive credit, and name me as a reference in the process.








As someone who grew up in an immigrant community and married into one, I think from a policy perspective there needs to be some boring limiting principles. I.e, maybe total % of population born outside the US, plus some sort of metrics around low vs high skilled immigrants.
Nativists have never been able to articulate a philosophical principle around nativism because there really isn’t one. In that way, the turn to “preferences” is refreshingly honest. That said, I think MOST people would agree that bringing in 1 billion non-Americans right now would be bad, regardless of their composition (as a hypothetical). With that context, the non US-born population is at all time highs, surpassing its late 19th-century record. There’s a reason why opposition to immigrants was an animating issue during times of high immigration and not, for instance, in the 1950s.
Articulating some sort of limiting principles in a way that appeals to both the restrictionists and the progressives (for whom this issue is not a priority) will be critical for achieving reform. Otherwise it will remain a hobby horse for the worst sorts of demagogues. Denmark has made meaningful progress here, and other western countries should take note.
I think if you had written this piece during a period of history when illegal immigration was low, I would have thought it appropriate and thoughtful, and mostly agreed with it (Though I think you do yourself a disservice to ignore people complaining about relatively recent developments with the abuse and expansion of H1B visa to hire skilled foreign workers in tech mostly to undercut American salaries, because they’re cheaper and have directly harmed the job market for tech workers. These tech workers are complaining about the immigration of “skilled” Indian workers precisely because they tend on average to be lower skilled than themselves, but also because they are being directly economically harmed. It would be worth acknowledging that many people do have real or perceived economic complaints even about legal immigration that are not based on racial bias. Even if you think they’re wrong to be worried, you should acknowledge the fear is based on immediate economic concerns, rather than other bases.)
But either way it’s hard to write this piece ranting about people who hate legal immigration being bad when it comes on the heels of long periods of sky high illegal immigration, and public sentiment on illegal immigration is very different, with most people thinking it is distinctly bad and wanting to slow it down and stop it. When it comes to immigration, it matters a lot which specific question is asked, and about the only area with broad support is the question of legal, skilled immigration. The anti-immigration parties are getting the support they’re getting precisely because elite party members have ignored and failed to address majority positions on controlling illegal immigration, and study after study have shown that (at least 2-4 years ago), the deepest misalignment between the general population and elected officials was their position on immigration and elected officials stance against broadly making serious efforts to control illegal immigration.
So yes, most people support legal skilled immigration. But your piece inexplicably ignores that the current noise and volume on immigration and support for anti-immigration parties comes from a majority desire to make it a controlled and orderly process, and a response against the broad idea and ethos behind decriminalizing illegal immigration (as many 2020 Democratic candidates endorsed).