Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Martin Greenwald, M.D.'s avatar

I hope we as a society remember why intelligence and ability are important before planes start falling out of the sky and things just stop working.

Racial quotas aside, it seems that over the last 20 years or so our country has almost completely given up on meaningful education and can only focus on getting the lowest performing students, many of them with no hope of an academic career, to pass some high school test. Everything is about credentials now, less and less about ability. The fact that this is now taking hold in medical school, law schools, and other similar institutions is scary.

The American ideal of political equality has, in the face of seemingly intractable racial performance gaps, so thoroughly morphed into a religious postulate of actual equality of ability, that I don’t think American society will tolerate truly race-neutral policies right now. The guilt and fear are too great, at least among some.

Jeebs's avatar

California shows the way. AA was banned in 1996 and rejected again in 2020. The UCs have been innovating ways around the law this whole time—both at the student and faculty level. Even so, the students are still weighted asian, so it appears the bans somewhat reduce discrimination at the student level.

76 more comments...

Ready for more?