61 Comments
User's avatar
main's avatar

I'm a woman who thought bringing back dinosaurs was a cool idea, but yeah Richard has already gone on a whole anti racism arc, so him becoming a progressive feminist is the next shoe to drop and I'll enjoy watching that.

Sam Fakahany's avatar

Anti-racist, pro-Jurassic Park, pro-organ selling progressive feminism is a boutique ideology if there ever was one. I wish Hanania luck on his new arc.

Yudi's avatar

Another female reader here interested in seeing Richard taper off the red pill. My recommendation is that he look into Paul Eastwick's new book Bonded By Evolution, which takes many red pill claims seriously and tests them against the evidence. It had a lot of information about compatibility and relationships that I was not aware of.

Lahey's avatar

I think Richard needs to cleanse his brain of the lame pickup artist stuff that he claims helped his confidence. Major blind spot

Lahey's avatar

Richard, why is it 5/5 more morally acceptable for men to be sexually promiscuous than women??

It takes two to tango. So these men are just knowingly degrading a woman's reputation and that's okay with you?

And fwiw, most women look down on promiscuous men so technically they're both being reputationally damaged.

main's avatar

He just wrote an article about how damaging causal sex is for women so it’s totally morally acceptable for men to be out causing women mental distress and harming their reputation according to him

El Toro's avatar

It is morally acceptable. Women have agency and can take responsibility for their own decisions. You can't socialize every aspect of life, it's unrealistic and goes against human nature. There need to be clear moral red lines, but also a scope for self-interested actions.

Miguel Madeira's avatar

But women don't need to be sexually promiscuous for men being sexually promiscuous - John can have sex with Anne and Lucy, but both Anne and Lucy only having sex with John (ofc, the other side of that equilibrium will be also many men as incels)

James Gillen's avatar

You might as well ask why women don't love The Three Stooges.

Ghatanathoah's avatar

Asking whether all human lives are equally valuable is underdefined. The way I tended to approach it when I filled out the survey was that all people have a "default" level of value that is equal, and then acquire additional value or disvalue through their actions. So Norman Borlaug and Ted Bundy started out equally valuable as all humans are, but their subsequent actions significantly changed how valuable they were, to put it mildly.

gordianus's avatar

Even that seems wrong. People with greater abilities are more practically valuable (or should be expected to be so), & a significant part of that is determined by genes.

Erika's avatar

Yes, all human babies are born innocent souls. The way Richard explains a few perspectives aligns with anti-egalitarian viewpoints.

Kira's avatar

Female reader here in favor of dinosaurs, I think the key to winning over a female coalition on the dinosaur issue is to develop the technology first to engineer sexy wolfmen and vampires, then transition to dinosaur-making once the tech is in place. The same technological stack would probably allow you to do both.

David Spies's avatar

There are no prehistoric mosquitoes carrying blood with sexy wolfman or vampire DNA trapped in amber

Natalia Bower's avatar

I have no idea why women don’t want to bring back dinosaurs. I also can’t really think of a good reason why not. Maybe they were thinking it should be a low priority?

Argentus's avatar

"Why Don’t Women Love Dinosaurs?"

Because all the weird fantasy mammals and birds after the dinosaurs and before us are cooler. That's my personal answer anyway.

T-rex is a big chicken monster. Meanwhile, dire wolves and Smilodon used to be a thing. New Zealand used to have giant eagles which could hunt and kill moa birds - which are bigger than ostriches. I like to hunt. The extinct Irish elk had antlers that could be 13 feet across.

The only dinosaurs that kind of blow my mind are pterosaurs because those things are basically just dragons. Some of the gigantic aquatic flesh-eaters are also pretty cool in a very Lovecraftian way.

I think the times the Earth was basically just an alien planet but still had life (when the atmosphere was totally different, when the whole planet was completely frozen, etc.) to also be more interesting than dinosaurs even if the only organisms around at the time were very primitive. Sponges in the ocean of an alien planet are more interesting than stegosaurus.

I was however rabid about dinosaurs when I was young so it may just be that the novelty factor is kind of gone.

*Edit*

"I wish there was a way to separate out persuasion from having different readers."

These aren't mutually exclusive. I reached an independent disgust threshold for the postliberal right around 2022 and sort of ended up here accidentally because "former heterodox rightist sympathizers who now think they are stupid for reasons of logic and principle and not mainly self-interest" is not a particularly big pool but one I was also in. Once I got here, ideas I read here led to refinement of what I now think (along with my reading of some other moderates and libertarians and my own nonfiction book reading).

I read a tremendous amount of more or less stupid leftism stuff over ten years ago and had long ago rejected that. I'm not a creature of epiphanies. I've never had one. It's more like I keep adding layers to a world model. I've taken whatever did make sense from each of these and discarded the rest. Cthulhu does mostly swim left. There are dialectical tensions in history. But these are not "one neat trick" explanations for everything - and it certainly doesn't follow that some extremely dodgy, simplistic ideological project should neatly and logically follow from these basic patterns.

"I’m also confused about how there can be so much disagreement with the idea of men and women having different roles in society."

I think I rated this one lower because of how it's phrased. It smacks of religious "great chain of being" sort of thinking. Or weird hippy arguments about equilibrium and balance. By a string of accidents that aided gene replication men and women evolved different phenotypes. This means when you leave them to do their thing, certain patterns of behavior will emerge. These aren't necessarily bad by default or the result of some conspiracy. But to say they have different "roles" speaks of some kind of telos type thing. Is humans' "role" to eat meat because we are omnivores? I'd probably have been neutral about it if the question was like "Men and women choosing different roles on average is a product of evolution" or "It is generally not good to try to force men and women to behave the same way."

I also voted a fair number of people a 3 because I didn't know who they were and there wasn't a "No opinion" or "Don't know them" explicit option.

R. Kevin Wichowski-Hill's avatar

With you on almost all of that. I want to resurrect Neanderthals, personally. What could be more interesting than that? Resurrecting pretty things we drove to extinction seems a good idea too, all else being equal.

The sexes thing is tricky. My sense is that, yes, evolution has made men and women different, but not *that* different. The problem is that in a completely laissez-faire society, which in other respects has much to recommend it, those modest differences plus some economic incentives will recreate oppressive gender roles lickety-split. People will *choose* them reluctantly and then find they can't get *out* of them easily, stereotypes will begin to flourish again, etc. and in the end, women can't self-actualize. So I support some of our feminism-inspired practices as a necessary evil to prevent drifting back into oppressive social roles that reduce the extent of self-actualization. If everyone were rich enough to farm out their domestic labor, this would not be a problem, but thus far, they're not.

I think Richard is wrong on the fat thing, but it's an understandable error. I think what people still don't get is that there is a difference in experience here that is akin to red-green colorblindness: those who can see the difference tend to be judgmental towards those who "refuse" to see the difference. Ask him again in twenty years when he too is struggling with his weight. Of course by then, we'll all be on GLP-1s so the topic will just disappear along with all the insulin resistance.

Argentus's avatar

I agree with this take on women for the most part. The way I have phrased this in the past is "women may want to be treated like women on average, but they mostly do not want to be treated like children." The other issue is that the historical average male unless socialized and disincentivized will use coercion as a tactic in sexual reproduction if he can. That + females being on average less able to resist physically + being more dependent for survival is not a recipe for anything like "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" for women.

This is also one of my more self-interested takes though and I have to admit that's most of my motivation for it. I actually do think that a fairly solid majority of women would probably be happy in more or less 1920s -1950s sexual/gender norms land and also think this would probably fix most of the fertility downfall. I also know I would be close to suicidally miserable. I hate "performing" femininity so much that I am borderline trans by like 1995 definitions of trans. Being allowed to be as much of a tomboy as I wanted to be is why I am happy in a female body.

So, I say rah rah artificial wombs, surrogacy, and transhumanism. Any and all technology that levels the biological unfairness at the biological level.

R. Kevin Wichowski-Hill's avatar

Amen to all that. My wife and I hired a surrogate (who was also a close friend, and our economic equal), so we're fanatics in favor of that. I find that I don't perform either side terribly well, so I use my beard instead of a silly pronoun announcement!

James's avatar

Man who doesn't like dinosaurs here. Not a huge fan of animals that want to kill and eat me. At least if they are anywhere near where I live. If they all live in I don't know somewhere else then I guess I'm cool with it.

Fuck bears, fuck hippos, fuck lions, and fuck dinosaurs.

DeepLeftAnalysis🔸's avatar

Sad to see Jeffrey Epstein rated lower than Steve Bannon, whose crimes were much more egregious. Stephen Miller has certainly caused more harm. And Jefferson Davis was a slave owner!

Joe Anderson's avatar

I can't think of what pressure by a boss to have sex could mean except blackmail.

On equal value of human life, I was thinking about the mandate of the legal system to look at everyone equally, not some ultimate value of their souls

userLNGHAMH's avatar

It could mean prostitution. Or some sort of dual-task job where you're a prostitute and a white collar worker like a cleric and a prostitute.

Robert Ferrell's avatar

Some years ago voters in Colorado chose to bring back wild wolves. It has not been a resounding success. Using that experience as a guide, I can understand why some thoughtful people would be hesitant to bring back dinosaurs.

Miguel Madeira's avatar

If you want a justification for the banning of boss-initiated sex harassment, try to think in terms of "contractual violation demanding tasks different from what was, implicitly or explicitly, defined in the job contract" (this will not apply to situations where was already previously defined that the employee was supposed to have sex with the boss - like, in the real word, the job of Virgina Jonhson to William Masters)

Kryptogal (Kate, if you like)'s avatar

Maybe what Richard should imagine is that Harvey Weinstein is his boss, and Harvey wants his penis, to earn a promotion (or not get blacklisted in industry). Or alternatively that some sexy woman is his boss, and she rewards 25 year old male twinks who sleep with her with raises and promotions, but has indicated no such interest in offering such things to Richard. Both should work.

Magnus Anderson's avatar

The trouble is, Richard probably thinks that the first case is okay and that he should just quit and work somewhere else and possibly write all his former coworkers that his boss is a weirdo

I'm sure Richard is pained daily by sexy women not wanting to sleep with him

Lucidus's avatar

As someone who lives in a very conservative environment where questioning Trump is the equivalent of saying God isn’t real, what is most disappointing about conservatism is both its obsession with minorities and the negating stance it takes. The more Nietzschean right hates life denial, yet they remain trapped in merely negating the liberal progressive worldview, instead of actually making one that’s worth inhabiting. They’ve got a whole big list of what we shouldn’t do, but very little to say on what would be a positive direction without slapping a generic go back to church pill on anyone to the left of them. Also, exposing that equality isn’t real for the right is then used as a justification for keeping everything the same. Tiresome.

Nude Africa Forum Moderator's avatar

I am very skeptical that 1 in 20 readers actually have an annual household income above $1 million. Particularly because you wouldn't expect people at that income level to take the time to fill out long surveys. Sure, there are probably some tech workers and the AI field is throwing money all over the place, but $1 million still seems quite rare unless they are factoring in equity somehow. People with $1 million incomes tend to be business owners, and I just don't see significant numbers of them spending their time reading substack articles and filling out surveys. Perhaps a "mischievous responders" effect. Or a handful of foreigners not doing a correct currency adjustment.

Buzen's avatar

It’s pretty easy to have over a million in capital gains if you’re old and sold off a big chunk of your stocks on “liberation day”, even if it was a mistake.

David's avatar

Biggest surprise to me here is that you're not biting the libertarian bullet on blackmail. Is that only blackmail for sex or for money also?

(I'm not biting that bullet either, but kind of would have expected you to on vibes.)

Kryptogal (Kate, if you like)'s avatar

You might think that the very, very small gender discrepancy in the responses, in and of itself, might cause you to rethink your sexism. Also, given that some of your biggest disagreements with your (mostly male) readers are over things I would categorize as artificial conceptions of women...trans, plastic surgery, forcing societal gender roles on them ... maybe that indicates that your general views on women are rather artificial and not very reality-based overall?? Something to consider.

I looked at the interactive demographic page, and if I limit things to Americans age 28-42, the number of sexual partners has virtually the same exact pattern between male and female respondents: about 20% have only had one partner, while about another 20% are 10-20 and a third 20% are 20 and above. Then the remaining 40% are randomly distributed between 1 and 9. Those results are remarkably similar as between male and female respondents, so maybe your theories on their sex lives and interests are what's skewed. The marriage rate in that group is also remarkably similar, with about 60% married and 40% not. Seems like they have very similar sexual habits which trend towards more rather than less partners, and it does not have a differential impact on them also mostly being married.

Richard Horvath's avatar

"I’m also confused about how there can be so much disagreement with the idea of men and women having different roles in society."

I think the libertarian solution is 'don't care' (imho = 3). You had the question phrased as 'Men and women SHOULD have different roles...', implying government or other societal institutions should encourage that on purpose. Letting merit, market, personal ethics decide the outcome whatever it may be is not a hard agreement with the proposition.

"favoring the death penalty, shooting fleeing felons...someone who rapes and murders a child should be treated humanely"

On one hand, you might have very high levels of faith in the accuracy of the justice system. Based on quick search, since 1973 in the US 203 people on death row were exonerated. Since that time 1683 people were actually executed. That is over 10% potential error rate just in this category.

On the other hand, vast majority of felons are not in the classes you despise. A quick search shows that the majority are "drug offenses" and "immigration offenses". When you demand felons to be shot, majority of people who would get shot are not child rapists or murderers but drug users and illegal immigrants.

Furthermore, you are potentially among them:

If you were to have sex with a 17 year old, you would become a felon yourself. A felon whom any political opponent would claim to be a child rapist, a claim that would survive a libel suit as per California law age of consent is 18.

Should the US copy the hate speech laws of the UK, you might become a felon just by posting the divisive, outside-of-the-overton-window opinions you are known for.

Max Wolf Valerio's avatar

I like the idea of reviving dinosaurs and if we could do that, we likely could do many other marvelous and more useful -- things. However, where would we put dinosaurs? They were often huge and exponentially stronger than any predators still on the earth -- how could we safely contain them? How could we humanely contain them? What would we feed them? I imagine they would eat quite a bit. They would also need a lot of exercise, and so -- room to move. Even a peaceful Brontosaurus would need room to move and tons of material to eat. We already have issues ethically with containing and training killer whales for our entertainment. What if they escaped in a crowded urban area? Or even in a rural area, I mean -- we are talking about live dinosaurs and not toy dinosaurs. So I voted "nay" or 1 on that one. Though I do love dinosaurs.

This was an interesting survey. It challenged me to consider my views. I do believe that your readers are generally a "classy" bunch, thoughtful and anti-conspiracy. Your critique of the right is timely and brave. At least someone's doing it from the right. The left does it all the time, but they have their own issues and their critiques are predictable. I like reading another somewhat politically homeless person, who has "been there, done that."

Also glad you see trans women as women and four is appropriate since, trans people in general are complicated beyond a binary understanding. I speak as one. Though I am a trans man and no one really cares that much, beyond some rabid TERFs and angry lesbians. Though there are a few... now that I think of it... Trad Catholics or especially Christian Nationalists. Being trans at all is a convenient whipping boy. There is a plague of people who tell other people what to do and how to live. I will be glad when they are no longer taken seriously, apparently they are now on ascension in popularity. But people like easy answers and yes, populism is all that.

I'm also with you on artificial wombs and transhumanism. Onward!

A radical feminist to read on artificial wombs is Shulamith Firestone. She was of the second wave of feminism. And, was forward looking on this subject in ways that appeared to be insane at the time her first book _The Dialectic of Sex_ was published - the early seventies. Though she seemed a crank... Well, apparently she was visionary.

Thanks for the insights!